Showing posts with label Macbeth. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Macbeth. Show all posts

Monday, February 9, 2015

Macbeth is Dead... Now What do We Do?



So, before I start talking about Dunsinane, the sorta sequel to that Scottish Play written by William Shakespeare all those years ago, I want to take a moment to discuss a rather large moment in Macbeth that is addressed quickly in Dunsinane. Mostly, the large handicap that comes from having one of the main characters in the follow up be someone who was killed rather famously in the first part. Or “seems” to have been killed.

They spend a lot of time on that word “seems.” 

Oh, and spoilers for Macbeth follow. If you haven’t seen it within the 400 years it’s been out, you may want to. It’s a pretty famous play. There’s a version starring Michael Fassbender coming out soon, and another that starred Patrick Stewart that’s already out. So pretty much whichever X-Man you prefer, there’s a pretty good version of it.

So, one of the main characters in Dunsinane, is Lady Macbeth going by the name Gruach in this and somehow all of the characters are shocked and surprised when (spoilers again) she betrays them all. Which is shocking in itself. This power-hungry woman who convinced her husband to kill the king has managed to fool us all! Who could have seen this coming?

Taking it back a step, Lady Macbeth returns for the sequel despite the notable handicap of being killed in the very first play, because William Shakespeare like to kill off characters like a power-mad combination of G.R.R. Martin, Joss Whedon, and Steven Moffat. You can complain about all of those guys you want; Shakespeare once had a guy pursued by a bear off stage because he felt like it. And that was in a comedy. Yeah, Martin, you enjoy your red wedding. Whedon, shoot Tara at the last minute. And Moffat, you kill off River Song as much as you’d like. Shakespeare laughs at you.

But here’s the deal that so many people tend to forget (because hack directors decide they want to show this very important moment on stage) - Lady Macbeth dies off stage. She has a moment where she has a mental breakdown, then goes off and supposedly kills herself. Or “seems” to. And yet here she is, fresh as a daisy and ready to resume her scheming in the sequel. Of course, I never bought it - it was her husband who didn’t have the stomach for killing at the start, despite being a warrior, so she goes in to finish the job. Then, stuff happens, and by the end of it their roles are completely reversed. She seems to be all crazy and Macbeth is the ruler who has a thirst for killing and not worrying about a little rebellion because the witches said - oh my God are those trees moving?

One of the smartest decisions made by David Greig was to bring Lady Macbeth here and gives her the historical name of Gruach, which was more like what her original name would have been back when Shakespeare was reading some old history books deciding which one he was going to turn into his next masterpiece. But they also bring her back, and despite the fact that she doesn’t have as much stage-time, she’s a large presence in the play itself, because, like the historical Lady Macbeth/Gruach, she has a claim to the throne. 

The play is about the aftermath of the death of Macbeth, starting actually around the time that Macduff and his army decide that they’ll just pretend to be trees. In fact, one of the first lines is very comedic - “here, you be a tree” which is a nice comment on the meta-theatricality of what we’re going to be watching. It’s a play, yes, but there are many layers of this play going on.  Siward just wants to bring peace to Scotland initially because it protects the borders with England. Malcolm, originally a symbol of order in the original play here is played almost aloof and unwilling to do what it takes to rule. And Lady Macbeth/Gruach is silently running her own campaign of violence. So there are roles within roles, within roles that everyone is playing. 

And yes, there’s the big honking metaphor that the production is in constant conversation with itself about: you can occupy a foreign nation all you want, but you can’t force everyone to sit down and play nice… even if you force everyone to try and sit down and play nice. 

Most of the play focuses on Siward, the English solider tasked with bringing peace - or at least a new Government - to Scotland. He is a fine character for us to follow, because it’s easy to take part in his descent. The play starts with his son being killed - for the greater good, of course - and he still has to protect his army who is growing increasingly frustrated. He has an affair with Lady Macbeth/Gruach, which makes it that more devastating when she has to marry Malcolm in a scheme to unite the warring Scottish Factions. I found his to be the most interesting section of the play, and I wish they’d spent more time on it. Lady Macbeth/Gruach is the one with the reputation for power and scheming above all else, and for a moment there’s a brief sense of real love between the two characters. But when it comes down to it, it’s not initially Lady Macbeth/Gruach who does the betrayal. Siward is so concerned about his legacy and “getting the job done” that it’s easy to see why she backslides into her old habits. As Siward continues his madness as his obsession with stabilizing Scotland slowly devolves into his obsession with Lady Macbeth/Gruach. Which asks the question: is it guilt? Madness? 

A lot of stories don’t really deserve a sequel. A lot don’t need them. At first glance, Shakespeare’s Scottish play doesn’t really need a sequel - and Shakespeare wasn’t above writing a sequel or two if the moment called for it. And others aren’t above writing sequels for him. I’ve seen sequels (usually in book form) to the Tempest, Hamlet, even Macbeth (focusing on Banquo’s son, who is not mentioned here. The witch part is played up, but the three witches/destiny thing is played down. WAY down.) But by producing a sequel, especially one as compelling as this one, so many years later… it’s a reminder that perhaps we haven’t learned all those lessons we have purported to learn. It’s a reminder that everything old can be new again, not just in the theatre, but in the world in general. 

This play asks a lot of questions, but answers few. Siward, relegated to “background character” and “guy we need to get on stage to get the actor playing Macbeth a break” in Macbeth is one that has divided loyalties, obsessions to duty and honor, and many character traits that make him a compelling character. I’m happy to see him given some of his due here as a take on a character who is initially pretty minor, but with a few tweaks is leading. Which gives me hope for the Bear in a Winter’s Tale, who’s story will be gladly told by the Royal Shakespeare Company one day. Maybe.


Dusinane is playing at the Sidney Harmon Hall in Washington, D.C. I highly recommend you take this opportunity to come watch this show. One of the things I enjoyed in London was the fact that on any given night the theatre was packed… I was disappointed to see that on a Saturday Night, opening weekend for a show the theatre was about half-full. (or half empty) It is a thought-provoking piece that manages to address a centuries old play while keeping in conversation with our current issues, and does so with tragedy, humor, and, well… lots of death.

Thursday, April 3, 2014

Shakespeare's Super Soliders



Tomorrow (or tonight for lucky people like me that have a ticket) the world will be amazed/astounded/nitpicking/hating/overanalyzing/generally mehing the newest superhero movie Captain America: The Winter Soldier. a.k.a Captain America: Those of us who read the comics already know who the Winter Soldier totally is, prepare to have your mind blown. 

As much as the armchair commenters that have to write and go on the news a whole bunch because they need content like to constantly complain about how we’re being overrun with this new fangled phenomenon of Superhero movies, the fact is we’ve been interested in Superheroes since we first thought of stories. Wasn’t Hercules just Superman in a toga? Zorro and the Scarlet Pimpernel were early Spanish and English versions of Batman. Our early warriors were all people who could do amazing things, from Beowulf slaying Grendel to King Leondius holding off an army of 10,000 with only 300 soldiers. (And was turned into a superhero comic/movie/action-fest.)  And without the fancy car, I guess. We’ve always been obsessed with people who can do those special things we wish we could do.

What makes Captain America so interesting is that he’s not just a superhero, injected with a Super Serum that makes him super (that’s a little redundant...) but he’s also a solider, which sort of makes him unique amongst the heroes of today. Superman is just a guy who was on the right planet at the right time. The Hulk is someone that needs to learn the importance of using “lead” and “radiation suits” when testing “nuclear bombs.” Even those that chose to take up the mantle of hero, like Batman and Iron man, are driven by some kind of tragedy that causes them to take up the mantle of hero. 

The fact that Captain America is a soldier is important. 

You know who else was obsessed with the idea of the soldier superhero? William Shakespeare. (The name of the series is Shakespeare 450. Where did you think I was going with this?)

William Shakespeare seemed to have a respect for soldiers, even if they ended up with some kind of tragic downfall. Keep in mind the tragic flaw is a pretty big reason a lot of heroes end up falling in tragedies, even today. Walter White was free and clear until his pride stepped in. So giving these superheroes tragic flaws are just part of the job, and not so much a comment on heroes. 

Yesterday I talked about Caius Marius, who went out and won a war, pretty much by himself in Coriolanus. Here was have a prime example of a super-soldier, loyal to a fault, willing to throw himself on the line not even for a cause or his hometown, but because he has a need to fight. (When asked to be domesticated, he runs to the front line to join the enemy!) His mother suggests that he shows off his scars to show how great a warrior he is.

There’s also everyone’s favorite general, Othello. He has almost magical powers. No, really, one of the charges leveled against him is that he managed to bewitch everyone into believing him. (Given the absence of witches, fairies, and wizards in this play, he probably didn’t. Shakespeare never had a problem using those.) Some people lived in fear of these magic powers to the point that they tried to kill him. But remember, before that he was a general loved, despite the fact that he was a Moor, living in Venice, which at that time didn’t go over to well. The fact that he was able to rise to such a power was... super! (I went there. Deal with it.)

Let’s not forget Macbeth, the cursed Scottish King. Again we have an example of a guy who does his best. When he meets the witches, he’s coming home from a successful battle. Let’s face it, he’s not the most heroic of Shakespeare’s characters, what with the murdering children and all, but he managed to work up a plot to kill a king, any of his supporters, and rise to power. Now there is some debate on whether he could have done this without murdering the king, but Macbeth is also a great Frankenstein story... the story of someone who is created, pushed into power, and then everyone wonders why it went south so quickly. But he makes the list because of his ability to lead an army, by force if needed. I’m also putting MacDuff on here, simply because when push came to shove it was MacDuff that commanded an army that destroyed the other guy, because he’s that awesome. 

Lastly, I’m going to put on there Sir John Falstaff, the Fat Knight. Not really “super” at first, until you get to his death in Henry V, and you realize just how much influence the funny dude had on the King. They were estranged at the end, but he is felt so much in a play he’s not even in, it’s uncanny. 


There are many other examples (such as Henry in Henry V.. that’s where we get the famous “St. Crispin’s Day Speech”) but I wanted to highlight these, because I believe them to be the most superheroic of all the soldier’s in Shakespeare’s play. They may not have done anything fancy like throw a shield, but they are pretty important as we look at Super-Soldiers in history.

Wednesday, October 30, 2013

This Halloween, Have a Piece of Pie... On Shakespeare


As mentioned, it’s that scary time of year, and this is the scariest day in all the scariest times of year: Halloween. Whether you’re planing on going out trick or treating, staying in and eating the candy meant for the trick or treaters, or making sure that everyone on your social media feeds know that this “candy” thing contains sugar, and sugar will eventually destroy all life everywhere, it’s important that you enjoy yourself today. (Seriously, though, if you hand out raisins I fully endorse the egging of your house every day until next Halloween.) Also Happy Halloween to all of you who are going to complain about people’s costumes.

Halloween can be a scary day, not just because of the sheer number of takes you’ll see on the “Wrecking Ball” costume or Miley Cyrus Twerking, but because there is a big push on what to do for this day. Do you go out? Do you stay in? What do you dress up as? (Please.... no more “Wrecking Ball” or Miley Cyrus Twerking Parodies... think of the pictures in about two years.) But what’s most important is: What do you watch?

I have an annual tradition of watching my most favorite of all ghost based Bill Murray movies: Ghostbusters. Of course then in about a month I watch my second favorite ghost based Bill Murray movie of all time: Scrooged. Ah, Bill, is there a holiday you CAN’T make a movie out of? 

But what you you literary types out there? The ones who would like to watch a movie, but still maintain an air of knowing that you’re learning something? Bad Shakespeare is here to help! There are a ton of great movies out their based on literature that are perfect for this time of year. Specifically, movies based on the works of the bard! (I was going to do all literature, but my list was mostly Frankenstein and Edgar Allen Poe. Seriously, read up his stuff. The man was insane.) Presented below is a list of the BEST Shakespearean adaptations for Halloween.




First up is Titus Andronicus. No, not the band that transcends genre but is classified as “Punk.” Here we’re talking about one of the first plays written by William Shakespeare, and definitely one of the first tragedies. It’s about a General who’s caught up in a cycle of revenge and honor with the Queen of the Goths.  (It’s got generals, goths, pies... you’ll love it!) This particular version stars Anthony Hopkins and isn’t really set in any time period, but is one of the most disturbing movies I’ve ever seen. It’s also one of the most violent plays Shakespeare ever wrote, and is probably closer to Saw than it is to what you think of as Shakespeare. This one will give you nightmares.




Next up is the Scottish Play, Macbeth, and I’m including two versions. One is Patrick Stewart’s quite excellent adaptation that moves most of the drama to a war torn country (that’s sort of the standard for William Shakespeare adaptations.) I’m also including an audio version of Alan Cumming one man adaptation, because when he’s not playing Nightcrawler, he can be a disturbing individual. I mean, just listen to it. Anyway, you know what it’s about, blah, blah, blah, witches, blah, blah, blah killing, blah, blah, blah cursed. The whole play itself is cursed. It’s like watching the Ring, only there’s no timeline on when someone is going to drag you down into a well. Or your play flops. I forget what’s supposed to happen here.




Next up: Any version of Othello or Hamlet. Except O. Which was terrible. They actually included a line that said, "I thought Shakespeare wrote movies." Just.... really? And Julie Stiles, you're supposed to be... you know what, I just need a minute. 

       Moving on. You want your horror psychological? How about we drive people mad. Othello is driven mad by his supposed friend, Iago, until he goes on a killing spree that involves killing himself. Iago is one of the rare exceptions to most of Shakespeare’s works in that one of the major villains meets his fate by being arrested, not by meeting the business end of a blade, or poison. He almost gets away with it! Hamlet is driven mad by himself, and possibly ghosts. But mostly himself. I’m throwing the Kenneth Branagh versions of both, because he did a good job. And plus, one of them has Neo in it. Neo, people. Neo.



Finally, Much Ado About Nothing. Why am I including a comedy on this list? Think about how absolutely disturbing this movie is. Yes, there’s the lighthearted romantic comedy between Beatrice and Benedict... oh, young love. They’ll get together, right? Yes, they will, after she asked Benedict to kill his best friend. Why? Because he’s so quick to anger that he throws away his true love once he sees her “cheating”. In a plot that is put together for no real reason or motive. Then when the plot is uncovered, does everyone laugh? No, no they fake Hero’s death. They make the young lover think that the love of his life kills herself. Seriously, people, this is some messed up The Game type stuff going around here. Yes, it ends happy because Shakespeare didn’t feel like having anyone eaten off stage by a bear. People are crazy.

Enjoy your Halloween, everybody!

Monday, September 30, 2013

Breaking Bad Shakespeare: The End








“The whole thing felt kinda shady, like morality wise.”
Skinny Pete, wrapping it all up for us.


I’m going to start this wrap up/analysis of Breaking Bad (And Breaking Bad Shakespeare) by saying... “wow.” There’s not a human being alive who didn’t think that this show wasn’t going to end with Walter White going to that big Meth Lab in the sky (or down below... he’s cooking the purest meth for Satan now, I guess) but I don’t think anyone could have called it exactly like that. Let’s get this out of the way: I thought his was a fantastic series finale.

Some of the debate seems to go around the idea that Walter White... Heisenberg... “won” despite the fact that he now has newly ventilated lungs. (It was one of those TV “vague shots to the midsection that could be a flesh wound, could mean he’s going to die” sort of things. I’d like to think it pierced is cancerous, cancerous lungs.) The thing is... Walter White didn’t win at all. Heisenberg won... his blue meth is off the street. Walt lost while winning, the grand tradition of tragic Shakespearean heroes everywhere.

First, let’s tackle how Walter White lost tragically. There’s a reason he started cooking meth: To save for his family. Walt was never going to fight to stop the cancer, he was never going to do battle, he was in give-up mode from day one. Make money, give it to his kids, bam. He took treatment when his wife turned around, made it about her, and then he was making money to pay for cancer treatments AND saving for his kids’ future, since he truly believed that it was futile. (This was before he was “good at it.” We’ll get to that line in a moment.)

Walt lost because he’s not giving his kids anything. Remember when Walter, Jr. “Flynn” set up a web page to save his father? Remember the outrage when Saul suggested that Walt launder the money through that? Remember when Walt didn’t want to be handed a job at Grey Matters because he had to earn it for his kids? Yes, Flynn won’t accept money from his father, so this the roundabout way he gives it to his kids, etc. But he loses out on the recognition. He loses out on the ability to say, “I provided for my family.” It was never about the money, and it wasn’t about the meth to start, it was about Walter White: hero to his family. Yes. Gretchen and Elliot will make sure Flynn gets the money. But Walt doesn’t get to say it was from him. It’s actually one of his worst nightmares.

I say this in the grand tradition, because other Shakespearean Tragic Figures have won by  losing like this. Claudius is exposed about 10 second before dying, after which Hamlet can go to his grave knowing that he won. Macbeth was king, and he did win... he didn’t lose his kingship to anyone woman born, nor until the trees of biram moved, which I’m sure comforted him for the 10 seconds his brain was still alive after it he was beheaded. King Lear learned his final lesson after his beloved daughter is killed. I put Walter White in this category. His pride got him into this situation. It’s by putting his pride aside that he’s able to achieve his goal of providing for his family. 

I was glad to see Jesse escape not just captivity from the Nazis (without having to resort to any bad language) but from Walter White. Had Jesse taken that moment to kill Walt, it would have meant he was trapped with him forever (alive for dead) but he was finally able to break free by NOT killing him. (He did see the blood, but at that point it meant nothing. He knew Walt was dead, but he wasn’t going to be the one to do it.) Personally, I felt that was one of the greatest moments of the show: Jesse finally free from Walter White. Jesse able to go make his own way.

The finale was full of little character moments like this, but I like that they were all framed around Walt. This is very much Walter White’s story. I’m glad they didn’t overplay Marie... just had her offer a word of warning to her sister. I’m glad we saw Holly, Flynn and Skyler again, but it was a nice reminder that their story ended back when they threw Walter out of their lives. (I know it’s television, but either Walt turned into a lot more of a master criminal than we thought, or the agents keeping tabs on her home weren’t very good. I do like the fact that Skyler didn’t immediately turn him back in.) 

The appearance of Badger and Skinny Pete was excellent for a few reasons, not the least of which being that it was a reminder that Heisenberg was a legend. I think that tended to fall flat for a bit in the final seasons. He was, as Hank (RIP) said, “A meth chef.” It’s also a nice call back to the start of the show, when they didn’t have the resources or the connection to call in an army to invade a compound, or to hire hitmen, like Walt was trying to do last episode. Gretchen and Elliot got taken by a pair of burnouts with laser pointers.

There were a few moments that fell flat for me (as with anything, really.) I really thought the final phone call from Lydia was a bit much... I would have much rather seen her coughing and get the implication that she was poisoned. The whole Gretchen and Elliot scene seemed off. Don’t get me wrong, I loved the casualness of Walter, strolling up to the door and his casual conversation. But I feel Walt needed more of a push against them. It was the two of them, dismissing him that caused him to spring back into action. Remember what I said before about losing his legacy? Here’s the physical representation of people that took it away from him. They didn’t have to die, but I just wish he had done more to address the fact they downplayed his involvement, even if he “understood why.” 

Then there’s Walt’s admission. I both loved and hated this scene. Talking to Skyler, he finally admits what everyone figured out since the time that he was noticed for his meth-cooking abilities, that he liked it, and he was good at it. I’m glad that the writers showed that he acknowledged it... he did this because he enjoyed it. I almost wish they found a way to incorporate it better. I almost feel that the last scene of the series, Walt walking through the meth lab before the police come, dying, shows this off better than anything that Walt could have said.

Let’s talk for one moment about Walt’s final act of redemption, shall we? I suspect that Walt’s original plan many not have involved saving Jesse, rather making him part of the bloody tableau that ended the show. Yes, it’s last minute redemption to remind us that Walt was never the ruthless drug kingpin he wanted to be. (Also, really, at this point what would killing Jesse serve?) It was immediately made a little selfish by the fact that he wanted Jesse to finish the job, to kill him

That last scene... I’m obsessed with last scenes. Even if I don’t watch a show, or I’m not interested in a book, I’ll do what I can to find out how it ends. I like thinking about the final image that a book or play or TV show will leave us. Last scenes are hard, though. Take Star Trek: The Next Generation. Personally, I hate the final scene of the series, because it wasn’t really. It was just waiting for them to head to the movies. Deep Space Nine, with Jake staring out the window... that to me is one of the finest final scenes a show has ever done. Obviously, with this show I was much more invested. This was a final scene. The deposed King, dying not with his family but in the place where he was truly great. This is up there in final scenes of a show, even if you didn’t enjoy the rest of the show. (and I know that some people didn’t enjoy it. That’s their right, even if they’re wrong.) But also, did you catch the way that Walter was wearing a green shirt and khaki pants... the same thing he was wearing in the first episode, when this all started. 

Ending the show the way it did... with Walter dying in a meth lab as the result of a self-inflicted accidental wound... ranks it up there with the great tragic heroes of literature. I’ve made this point many times, and I’m going to make it again: Breaking Bad should rank up their with great literature. It needs to be rewatched, studied. We’re going to need to discuss this for years to come to catch the symbolism. I enjoyed it. And I look forward to watching it again. 

Friday, September 20, 2013

Breaking Bad is Literature





You know, since I started working on this blog while Breaking Bad is airing, I’ve started putting this little tag letting you know that I’ll be covering spoilers. Is it even necessary? I mean, I post these the Friday after the episode aired. That was on Sunday. Did you really manage to avoid everything until then? If you didn’t, then you deserve to have me tell you that the episode ended with Walt turning into a Dragon and attacking Arizona. Grrr. Arrggh.

As you may know, next week is Banned Books Week. Which means we’ll be taking a break from Breaking Bad Shakespeare Fridays. I’ll be doing a special on Monday analyzing if it ended as a Shakespearean piece, or merely as something Marlowe may have slapped together to cover his drinking debts, because screw Marlowe. You heard me.

In the meantime, and in the spirit of Banned Books Week next week, I wanted to take a special look at Breaking Bad in the spirit of banned book weeks. Mostly, this show that I’ve been comparing to a Shakespearean tragedy (because it very much is a Shakespearean tragedy, and there are people with phD’s that agree with me, not just a guy with a blog and three days to fill. (I suppose I could cut back, but here I am...). Many of the themes are the same, the body count is lower than in a lot of Shakespearean Plays, the violence is just about the same, but I think you’d be hard pressed to find someone to put Breaking Bad in a classroom as an example of great literature. (Never mind that Shakespeare didn’t write a word of his plays to be read, he wrote them to be performed, yet we say how Shakespeare is nothing but literature.) 

Quick note: some of this post is because of last week’s Breaking Bad, in which we poured some Schraderbrau on the curb for ASAC Schrader. However, I hope that people understood that in an episode that contained a shootout between two DEA Agents and a group of Meth-Dealing Nazis, both DEA Agents being murdered, the brutal torture and imprisonment of a guy, a knife fight between a husband and wife, and the kidnapping of a baby, the helpful censored made sure we didn’t hear any naughty words in the form of ASAC Schrader’s final “Fuck” to the bad guys. I’m glad that we got to think of the kids in the audience not hearing any bad words before Walt confesses to letting a woman die because she was getting in the way of his Meth-Cooking.

That brings me to my point of Breaking Bad and Shakespeare, mostly with violence. The body count in Shakespeare’s plays are pretty high. There’s murder (most foul), rape, suicide (oh, my... the suicide), torture, and one instance of a pie that would make the writers of Saw sit down and say, “hey... maybe Shakespeare should have toned it down a little bit.” At what point do we trade off violence (and some language) for the “literary factor.” Let’s face it, there’s symbolism in Shakespeare, there’s symbolism in Breaking Bad. I can’t stress enough: Walter White should be up there with the great pantheon of Shakespearean characters. He’s got pride, jealousy, no matter how far down the rabbit hole he goes, he’s doing it all for his family and can justify it (until his wife pulls a knife on him.)

So what makes something “literary”? Is it because a bunch of guys in wigs decide that something is literary? (That’s how they do it right? Or am I thinking of the British Legal System.) What makes, say, Hamlet more literary than Alan Moore’s The Killing Joke, which many consider to be one of the best in the medium? Why is Macbeth great art when Breaking Bad is “just a TV Show”? Again, I’m using Shakespeare not just because this blog is called “Bad Shakespeare” and not just because I’ve been comparing the two for the past however many weeks (I’m too lazy to go back and count. Someone do that for me.) but because Shakespeare wrote PLAYS. Things up on the stage for us to see. Things that would be interpreted a certain way because an actor decided that Hamlet should be played as depressed flimmaker in 2000. (Damn you, Ethan Hawke. Just... damn you.) Or because Wesley from Angel should dive in the grass as much as possible while people try to trick him.

I guess I’m getting at the central question I’ve asked plenty of times: Is Breaking Bad literature? I’d say yes. Yes it is. But something like this would be banned from classrooms, because of it’s violence and language. (Oh, and Shakespeare LOVED the bad language. He just hid it better than we do today.) But this violence and language... it’s nothing compared to what we’ve seen in the past. It still has all those juicy elements that I would love to tackle in a classroom, and do so in a way that will help kids learn something about revenge tragedies, fatal flaws, symbolism, and everything that Shakespeare would love to teach us. Because Shakespeare loved the bad guy, and show us what made him tick.

But hey, don’t take my word for it. Here’s Aaron’s speech at the end of Titus Andronicus, where he curses the fact that he can’t do more evil.

AARON. Ay, that I had not done a thousand more.
Even now I curse the day- and yet, I think,
Few come within the compass of my curse-
Wherein I did not some notorious ill;
As kill a man, or else devise his death;
Ravish a maid, or plot the way to do it;
Accuse some innocent, and forswear myself;
Set deadly enmity between two friends;
Make poor men's cattle break their necks;
Set fire on barns and hay-stacks in the night,
And bid the owners quench them with their tears.
Oft have I digg'd up dead men from their graves,
And set them upright at their dear friends' door
Even when their sorrows almost was forgot,
And on their skins, as on the bark of trees,
Have with my knife carved in Roman letters
'Let not your sorrow die, though I am dead.'
Tut, I have done a thousand dreadful things
As willingly as one would kill a fly;
And nothing grieves me heartily indeed
But that I cannot do ten thousand more.”

Wednesday, September 11, 2013

Breaking Bad Shakespeare: Lady Macbething as an Art Form


Once again, a note: We’ll be talking about some of the more recent developments on Breaking Bad. If you haven’t watched them when they aired, downloaded legally or illegally, read the recaps, or hired Bryan Cranston to be the scariest clown at your birthday party, then I’m assuming you don’t care if you’re spoiled. And if you care that you’re spoiled at this point, then please look up the word “apathy” in the dictionary. 

Today, I’m going to do a little something for the ladies. Hello, ladies...

At this point in the show, both Skyler and Marie are being drawn more and more into the world of Walt aka Heisenberg, and Hank aka.... Jesse puncher. And as we do, the term, “Lady Macbeth” gets thrown around a LOT. Like, all the time. Skyler is all Lady Macbeth because she’s all like “what’s one more person?” in the killing of Jesse Pinkman, and Marie is like Lady Macbeth because she’s like “So are you going to sacrifice him” about being Jesse Pinkman... (You know, at this point the last scene should just be Pinkman dancing on all of their graves.)

I don’t really think that means what people think it means. (Yay. Princess Bride references. Tune in next week when I work in Miracle Max.)

William Shakespeare... you mind if I call him Billy? Billy really enjoyed writing his characters, but he wasn’t really known for writing “strong female characters.” Ophelia kills herself pretty much because of Hamlet. Desdemona lets herself be strangled. Viola, who’s often held up as “look, here’s a strong female character because she takes charge!” is almost found out because she falls in love with the guy she’s “helping.” So many times, when someone wants a strong female character, they throw Lady Macbeth into the mix, and say, “hey... she’s pretty strong!” And she is. She’s also pretty take charge. 

Macbeth is set back when Regicide was pretty illegal, and not just what Archie wanted to do in many issues of his comic. To even discuss it usually got you a pretty hot date with Madam Guillotine. So, it’s important to note that the entire scene where Macbeth comes home and talks about his crazy day of meeting witches and being told that he’s going to be in charge of the throne he was talking about eventually, when the king died. Lady Macbeth talked him into it, just barely. Then later, when she’s all like, “frame his guards!” and Macbeth is all like, “no” she’s the one who walks into the room, then frames the guards. 

Then she promptly kills herself out of guilt. Suicide... it’s what Shakespearean women had for dinner, apparently.

Regardless, let’s go back to my point, rather than a paragraph I framed around making a pun about Reggie and regicide. Skyler and Marie aren’t really Lady Macbeths so much as they’re just fighting on their respective sides of the law. Even when they have the tense/wonderfully framed scene around the table side guacamole, Marie dedicates most of her hatred towards Walt, not her sister. 

The issue continues to be that the women, while stronger than they were at the start of the series when they basically were props to get Hank and Walt to have an active relationship, then to have Walt have something to do, but they still aren’t doers. 

Skyler probably comes the closest to Lady Macbething the whole thing up. She does take an active role in the money laundrying scheme with her magical accountant skillz. She has a few plots of her own, like getting her kids out of the house, but most of her killing is relegated to wanting to kill Jesse Pinkman. (Damn... it really sucks to be Jesse Pinkman this season.) Most of her plotting has been to get Walt AWAY from the Meth, AWAY from the dangerous life... 

I know that Skyler actress Anna Gunn recently wrote an op-ed to the New York Times that talked about the reasons everyone seems to hate Skyler. One of the more interesting points is that she thinks it has to do with the fact that “she’s Walt’s equal.” Here’s the thing: She’s not, really. That’s not to say she’s not smart, she’s not capable... she was the one cooking the books, not Walt. I think when making this argument people tend to forget just how manipulative and.... quite frankly how evil Walt is. Skyler’s whole point has been getting herself out of the predicament that Walt got her in, and while she’s shown some signs of manipulation (the earliest being those annoying scenes where she made Walt’s cancer all about herself) she hasn’t quite gone to that level. Even this week, when she wanted to kill Jesse, she wasn’t willing to go the whole way... she couldn’t even say, “kill him” just hint at it.

Skyler and Marie are certainly an interesting pair. I’m going to be interested to see where this goes next... well, I’ll just hit up some random speculation. What will really be interesting is to see what is going to happen once Walt and Hank are removed from the situation, either by Uncle Jack or... let’s just say other means. (My prediction: Walt is kidnapped and forced to cook for Uncle Jack, Hank is probably kidnapped as well and used as bait. This will take us to the time jump we’ve seen at the start of Season 5.) Right now they are women defined as their relationship to their husbands. Which while similar to Lady Macbeth, it was pretty evident that she wasn’t defined by her husband so much as she was trying to lead him to a fancier life. Right now they're not so much Lady Macbeths as something else entirely.

Of course, for all the speculation of who Walt is going to kill, let's just say that this world as a Shakespearean Tragedy isn't as kind to it's women. 

Friday, August 30, 2013

The Tragic Flaw...


Quick note: This post is going to contain spoilers for some of the “Final Season” episodes of Breaking Bad. I’ve generally tried to keep my analysis a season behind, but something came up that was so juicy, I had to work it into my analysis. What will follow is part of the discussion for “Buried” the second episode of the Final Season. Or the 10th episode of the 5th Season. I’m really fuzzy on the math of this. But if you haven’t watched it live, through DVR, old school videotape, had your friends re-enact the episode for you, or downloaded it legally or illegally, then I strongly suggest that you’re probably a time traveler from the 18th century. and you’re not sure what Breaking Bad is and why we choose to stare and glowing rectangles for so much of our lives. In which case, I have some other spoilers for you, and we can talk later. Onto Breaking Bad Shakespeare Friday!

Shakespeare loved the tragic flaw. In fact, when studying Othello, King Lear, Hamlet, or Macbeth (the big four tragedies), chances are pretty good that your teacher (albeit not as handsome as me) probably started out the discussion with a brief overview of each of the main character’s tragic flaws. (Inevitably screwing up Macbeth’s tragic flaw and mixing it up with Lady Macbeth’s but that’s another post.) But what a lot of people don’t cover is the fact that the “tragic flaw” is available in all flavors, and affects so many of the other characters. In Othello, the argument could be made that as much as Othello is jealous and easily manipulated, so are Desdemona (she let’s her husband kill her) and Iago (who throws everything into motion because he’s jealous of this dude who’s skin color is not the right color for him and has everything he wants). Most of Hamlet could have been avoided had they had a sitdown at the start of the play rather than taking advantage of all the madness, corruption, and paranoia. The play may have been shorter. And Macbeth is about a dude who’s kind of happy until he gets the idea to be ambitious, then his wife got all ambitious, too. Then Macduff gets all revengy and ambitious. Then they all die. As Bruce Willis might say, “Macbeth won’t be attending that hat convention in July.” (He gets beheaded, so the line is hilarious.)

My point being that the same with Breaking Bad: everyone has spent a long time analyzing Water White’s tragic flaw, which is a combination of pride and ambition. He’s too proud to accept help, so he has to go on and cook meth to pay for his treatments. (At the point in the series that he’s offered financial assistance by his former business partners, he’s already had one major failure as a drug overlord and had to murder two people. One of them he strangled with his bare hands.) Pride and ambition have long been associated with people on this show. Jesse throws out several batches of meth because he can “do better.” Gus Fring... oooooh, we’ve talked about good ol’ Gus, but when Walter crossed paths with him and hurt his pride, how long did it take him to go all boxcutter on people? 

But there’s one line that sums everything up, for me at least. Last week on “Buried” we get the conclusion to the long awaited showdown between Heisenberg and Hank. This is the moment that Hank has been waiting on for a year, and we’ve been waiting on for five. Then the moment is over as the two men run to their respective wives, and eventually Hank ran to Skyler. While confronting her, he let of this gem of a line: ““He looks me in the eye and says ‘If what you think you know is true.' IF!” 
Had anyone told me that line without the context, I’d look at you and say, “That’s a great line from Walt. Writing like that shows us what’s going on in his head.” But that’s Hank. Hank who’s pride is hurt, not from the fact that the Meth Druglord he’s been hunting for the better part of the year is his brother-in-law, but from the fact that he’s being taunted. The fact that he’s being underestimated again. That despite the fact that he’s figured out that his brother-in-law is Heisenberg, he can’t get the confession he wants. He can’t get the few words that he wants: “I am Heisenberg.” 

It’s things like this that push the show over the edge from mere entertainment to something deeper. To something that is more Shakespeare-like. I’m interested to see where we go from here. Really that line starts to seal up Hank’s fate: He’s going to have to die. Hank’s pride is going to get in the way, the same as Walt’s pride affected him, the same as Skyler’s pride is starting to affect him. The whole thing is just going to keep going in a vicious cycle, much like Macbeth or Othello or Lear. Now we get to add White to that list, and all the prideful people around him.

Friday, August 23, 2013

About that Macbeth Moment...


There’s a rule in film. No matter what, you don’t kill kids, and you don’t kill pets. Doing that is generally short hand for “the guy you’re dealing with is really, really, really bad”. In fact in Jaws,  Steve Spielberg (who’s like... the Orson Welles of filmmaking) kills off a kid and his dog early on so you knew that the shark wasn’t like other sharks... he was an evil shark, possibly built on an ancient indian burial ground.

So let’s talk about Macbeth for a minute. Macbeth takes the whole “no killing kids” thing very seriously, with Macbeth ordering hits on two kids - one to prevent his prophesied successor, and one because he was the son of his chief rival. Up until this point in the play, we could sorta get behind Macbeth. After all, he had no real plans to be anything more than a really good soldier up until he came upon some witches in the woods. (And can you blame him? If you encountered some witches in the woods, what would you do? I’d probably try to be king. And eat their house, if it’s made of chocolate.) After the witches tell him that he’s going to be the king, it’s his wife that helps to ensure that the position gets vacated. I mean, he’s not a nice man, but he’s hardly the monster that deserves to be (SPOILER for a story that’s been retold a billion) decapitated at the end of the story.

That’s a lot of buildup for us to start discussing Breaking Bad’s Macbeth moment: the killing of Drew Sharp. 

The body count on Breaking Bad has never been what one could consider low, and Walter White has had his hand in a lot of it, even if he hasn’t pulled the trigger. Jane, Gus Fring, Gale, Crazy Eight, the two random thugs... it’s an impressive list for a guy who was giving F’s to lazy students a few months back. And yes, it was evil Todd not Walter that pulled the trigger on Drew, the young kid who saw a bunch of men filling up a tub in the desert. 

Was the killing of Drew a necessary death? Not really. At this point he watched a bunch of guys filling up a tub. And they didn’t really know how much he actually saw. He was a kid. On a dirt bike. That could have fled if he really thought he saw something, or if he thought he was going to be in any danger. But these were all arguments made by characters on screen (Specifically Jesse.) 

The problem has been Walt’s reaction. His reaction is what proves to be our Macbeth moment. I’d argue that this is our tipping point where we no longer are watching Walter White. Walt’s gone. We’re now watching Heisenberg.

Walt was never going to win a contest for least selfish person alive. Jesse even reminds him at one point, “hey... you only needed 300,000 dollars for your kids...” But most of the deaths he’s caused have been to protect himself of Jesse. Gus Fring was threatening him. (Although I figure that given a long enough timeline, Gus was going to be killed by Walt... that’s another post.) Jane, while he didn’t kill her, was taking Jesse down a dark path. The thugs were going to kill Jesse AT THAT MOMENT. The most innocent is probably Gale, but at the time he was working with Gus, and posed a direct threat to Walt and Jesse. Also, let’s face the fat that as fun and lovable Gale was, he was cooking meth for a brutal drug lord. Gale, while “quirky” and “fun” was really a gun and an ego complex away from being Walter White. (That’s another post) Even Crazy Eight tried to kill Walter TWICE. These were deaths that, while brutal, were things we could get behind in some way. 

The problem with Drew is the fact that 1) Todd shot him... Todd, who was trying to break into the business. Todd, who was trying to impress Heisenberg/Walt. Todd, who’s really the first of Walt’s henchmen. (Not a partner or paired with him, working for someone else.) 2) They pulled the train heist the way the did SO NO ONE WOULD DIE. 3) they had no idea what he saw. 4) they cleaned up the crime scene, and that was that. The end. Goodbye to Drew, who was reported missing, and really not mentioned by Walt again. 

The placement of this death is also interesting. Macbeth has Macduff’s son murdered in act 4, just before the ramp up to the final act... same with the death of Drew. It’s the ramp up of the final act that starts to bring the true character of Walter (and Macbeth) to light. No longer are we dealing with the sympathetic characters that are victims of their circumstance... these are characters who are brought those circumstances on themselves, they just didn’t take ownership of it. It’s something that we’re going to see more of as the final act is upon us. 

Thursday, August 8, 2013

Breaking Bad Shakespeare Friday: Why We Love George Clooney, but Not Andy Garcia


So here we are. On Sunday, Breaking Bad enters the final eight episodes that will tell us if this goes down as a Shakespearean Tragedy, or a mere Marlowean... Marlowe... thing. I guess. In any event, as you can tell I’m fairly excited to see just how it’s going to turn out.

But why?

Breaking Bad, as anyone knows, focuses on some not nice people doing not nice things. (Contrary to the beliefs of people who know of the show and do not watch it, it does not glamorizing anything, except pork-pie hats. Pork pie hats are awesome.) So... who are we rooting for in all of this? Are we rooting for Skyler, who’s moral stand against what Walt was doing lasted about as long as it took to realize they were really, really rich? Are we rooting for Hank to take down Walt? Are we rooting for Jesse to turn his life around, finally? Or are we just enjoying the ride?

One of the great things about this show is that it taps into the age old tradition of making “heroes” (or at least people we are rooting for) out of the Bad Guy. Basically, think of it this way: Andy Garcia wasn’t a “nice guy” during Ocean’s 11. But he owned a casino. The money that George Clooney and Brad Pitt was stealing was rightfully his. But we wanted those 11 guys to walk out with the money, and we wanted George Clooney to ride off into the sunset with Julia Roberts, despite the fact that he had better chemistry with Brad Pitt. 

Great stories are filled with the “hero” of the story being bad men that were compelling to follow. Think about one of my favorites, Macbeth. It’s hard to bounce back from the fact that he rose to power by listening to a group of witches then murder, then he orders the death of a child. Maybe we forgive the occult, maybe we forgive the murder, even, but when you start killing children out of paranoia, that’s pretty much the end of it right there.

Yet, Shakespeare pretty much sets himself as the “hero” of the story. Macbeth is the story of Macbeth. (And the closest parallel to Breaking Bad: The story of a man who is seen as not living up to his potential who works to become a king.) But we follow this man who is doing terrible things because we strive to understand why.

The evolution of Breaking Bad is similar to that. We understand Walt’s struggle at the beginning. We can even start to understand his struggle with wanting to help his family himself. At what point do we have to stop empathizing with Walt? At one point do we stop rooting for the bad guy? At what point do we want Walt to fail? At what point do we want Macbeth to fail? At what point do we want George Clooney and Brad Pitt to just finally kiss and get it over with? (That’s another post.)

Deep down, I don’t think we do. I think it comes down to point of view. No one can argue that Walt is a nice man, that ship sailed probably around the time that he watched Jane die. (At least for me. I’m sure we all have our own “Walt is irredeemable” moments.) I think what we want to see is the story as it’s been put in front of us. This particular story is the Tragedy of Walter White. This particular story isn’t about the good guy Hank taking down Walter. This isn’t the story of Skyler leaving her husband. (In fact, the reaction of people towards Walter is pretty telling... people find her annoying, not sympathetic because she’s trapped in a marriage with a murderous drug overlord.)

To me, this is why the last eight episodes are so important. Despite the murders, drugs, attempted rape... so many other things... we’re still seeing things through the eyes of Walter White... Heisenberg... the “hero” of Breaking Bad. I want these last eight episodes to continue this. I don’t want a shift in perspective. I want us to keep following our villain until the very end.

Here’s hoping.

Wednesday, July 24, 2013

All About Controversy!


Like many other people, one of my first forays into science fiction was the extremely classic Ender’s Game. For those who haven’t read it, you probably should. It’s about a young boy who is trained to help stop an insect-alien invasion of Earth. (Which is different than Starship Troopers, trust me, but when Earth really meets a race of insects that’s peaceful, they’re going to take one look at our literature and we’re going to be pretty screwed.)

Of course, if you’ve been following anything about this movie, you know that the writer, Orson Scott Card is... well, let’s just say passionate in his defense of a political view that’s opposite of a lot of people’s including mine. Basically Card believes that gay people shouldn’t be allowed to get married. (That’s the nice way of putting it. He believes a lot of things I’m not going to post here.) While personally, I don’t care what anyone does because I’m too busy leading my own life to really focus too much on what someone else who means no harm is doing.

But of course, that has launched the giant debate: should we ignore all of Card’s work because of this belief?

The thing is, I don’t think we should be ignoring his work because of this. I think we need to keep an artist’s work separate from their beliefs.*

Ender’s Game is good science fiction. I read it well before I knew anything about Orson Scott Card. (I read it in the days when Google was not widely available or yet invented, so you couldn’t plunk down the name of someone and learn everything about them in mere seconds.) So, I’ve read the information. I checked the book out of the library (so I guess I screwed him out of the commission... take that, I guess?) and even though I find Orson Scott Card the man a reprehensible, I find the writer very good.

Last year the CEO of Chick-Fil-A said some similar things, and the outrage was huge on both sides. “How dare he say that!” one side said. “He has ever right!” the other said. “Hey, I own a restaurant and I want as many people as possible to shop there so I’m going to keep my mouth shut about things like this!” no one thought of saying. But people attempted to organize a mass boycott of Chick-Fil-A while another group attempted to organize a mass buy of greasy chicken nuggets, just like it says to do in the Bible. (Right after gluttony is a sin, I guess?) But I remember one comment that came down then, and I apologize to the comedian that said it (Google has failed me!) but they said something along the lines of “I drove around for four hours looking for a place that supported my political views for lunch.” 

It’s a movie. It’s a book. It’s not two hours of Orson Scott Card screaming about his political views on gay marriage. Like I said, it exposes some deep anti-Insect Alien propaganda, but he’s hardly the first. (I however, welcome our alien overlords, whether they be insect, lizard, cat, or some other crazy thing. Please don’t be alien robot, though. That crosses the line.) Also, I read the book, what do I do now, get one of those Men in Black flashy brainy thingies to erase my memory? Because I tried after going to see the Last Airbender, and those things are expensive.

Again, I’m not saying that I respect anything this man says. I think what he said was horrible. But he’s one of a billion and a half people that has worked on this movie. Do I boycott Harrison Ford, Han Solo himself who actually spoke out saying that People like Orson Scott Card have lost? Do I boycott Assistant Gaffer Frank Cunningham who just wanted to make a movie? Do I boycott my teenage dream of seeing this movie put up on the screen, albeit starring Chris O’Donnell who was the greatest actor of my generation apparently?

The Orson Scott Card situation is an extreme example, of course. It’s an example of someone that got in front of a camera and said his beliefs (which I can respect, even if I think he has his head up his ass) and they happen to be terrible beliefs. For other examples of extreme “should we boycott” also see Polanski, Roman, who’s The Scottish Play, which again I saw before I knew who he was and had access to his crimes,  (damnit, Google, why weren’t you invented sooner?) was one of the defining moments in my understanding and loving Shakespeare. I can’t imagine a world where I haven’t seen his Macbeth... it came along at the right time, at the right moment for me to hit on Shakespeare. I didn’t know who he was, or what he’d done. What he did was terrible. What he created changed the course of my life.

We have to separate the art from the artist. Do you really want to dig deep into your book/art/movie collection to see what everyone has said and done and boycott them for it? If you dig deep enough, you’re going to find a reason to boycott everything. Ender’s Game is not Orson Scott Card’s anti-gay screed. It’s a violent science fiction book. That looks like a great movie.

Tuesday, May 21, 2013

The Answer is A). Standardized Tests Suck

            

                                      Shakespeare cat hates Dixon Ticonderoga Pencils


                The name of the cat in Macbeth is Greymalkin.
                I do have a point with that first statement, and we’re going to get back to it in a little bit, but last week while I was talking Star Trek and phasers and pew-pew! Warp speed, Mr. Sulu! I know that some kids were sitting down to take the Standards of Learning Tests. (Known as SOL’s.)
                I want to make this perfectly clear: I hate standardized tests. I don’t feel they contribute much to society except the amazing ability to take one day of a kid’s life and say, “take this test” and hope for the best that the kid remembered enough facts to fill in an oval with a number 2 pencil correctly. I’ve never seen a number 1 or number 3 pencil, so I’m not sure why we stuck with number 2. God help you if you use a mechanical pencil, pen, or crayon. You will use a Dixon Ticonderoga Number 2 Pencil, and you will love it.
                Of course, in memorizing these facts long enough to make sure that kids can fill in an “A” properly, there’s very little focus on whether or not anyone is understanding the answer properly. That brings me back to my first statement up top. The name of the cat in Macbeth is Greymalkin.  So, um… where does he show up and why is he important?
                Greymalkin has one mention: when the witches are casting one of their spells, or doing whatever it is they witches in that play do. Did they set Macbeth on a path with newly stoked ambitions where he believed him invincible enough to plot the death of a king, and later his closest friend? (Oh, spoilers for Macbeth. ) Or did they accurately predict the future, one that would not be altered had they not encountered the future king wandering around the forest? Or was it all a dream, and the lost ending featured Macbeth waking up and finding Patrick Duffy in the shower. (Oh, spoilers for Dallas, too, I guess. Shakespeare and JR. You’re getting it all today folks!) And where does Greymalkin fit into all of this?
                The official answer, of course, is that he’s a familiar, which puts the witches in league with the devil. Also, if you read carefully and do that research thingy, you may find that possibly many of the witch scenes weren’t written by William Shakespeare. In fact, there’s an entire scene that clearly wasn’t written by him, and added later. (I’m going to let you find that one on your own. RESEARCH!) But again, where does all of this fall into the grand spectrum of my point, that has been lost amidst the jokes about Macbeth and the not easy target of mentioning that Patrick Duffy once placed Aquaman?
                Quick, which play featured a cat named Greymalkin?
A.      Macbeth
B.      A Doll’s House
C.      The Importance of Being Ernest
D.      The Book of Mormon
You hopefully picked A and filled it out on your answer sheet, filling in the oval completely. Yay! You have done the bare minimum to pass the test! You can’t tell me the significance of the floating dagger in Macbeth, the rise of feminism in A Doll’s House, the Importance of Being Ernest’s satire of the rich, or why the Book of Mormon is an important musical. (It’s like brand new, but the soundtrack is awesome. You should see it. And take me.) But you can name a cat that showed up in one line of a play. That’s cursed. And the cat doesn’t really do anything. He doesn’t slay the title character. (I really have to stop saying it’s name.) He doesn’t even really represent anything, other than the tidbit of knowledge of what real witches talked like back then. It’s like someone studied Nicolas Cage for a few years then wrote True Blood because they assumed that all vampires talk and acted like that. (I just imagine his house is very much like that show.) That’s my point. Knowing one random fact proves nothing. Being able to bubble in a letter proves nothing. There’s no mention of the understanding behind the fact. This is true of any subject. Boiling things down to one stressful day doesn’t help. It only seeks to apply a black and white answer to an increasingly gray world. (A Greymalkin world? No? Anyone? Is this thing on?)
Of course, if you’re unsure of what to pick, I’d go with “C”.